We assess accuracy, intent, readability, duplication, internal links and available performance data before deciding what deserves attention.
Refresh without needless URL loss
Where a page has value, we prefer improving it over deleting it casually. Merges or moves require checking relevant URLs, links and appropriate redirects rather than sending everything to the home page.
Review quality before and after
The real test is whether the page answers the reader's question more completely and helps them proceed. Performance can be monitored where data permits, without assigning certainty to every ranking movement.